A Pyrrhic Victory in DC (at best) and the Looming California Battle

December 23rd, 2009 by admin Leave a reply »

Originally posted by Alberto Saavedra on DailyKos on Tue Dec 15, 2009 at 10:10:17 PM

Some healthcare legislation will pass in DC in the next few weeks. And Obama will sign it.  Commemorative pens will be used.  And pictures will be taken in the White House lawn. Obama will give a nicely worded speech.  Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi will ham it up.

But this will not be the glorious event it could have been. The progressive base will not rejoice but the insurance companies will, people without health insurance will not celebrate but teabaggers will, healthcare activists will not high five each other but Republican politicians will.

This healthcare victory will be a Pyrrhic one (at best).

The only hope we will have is that a progressive state passes a good Single Payer Public  legislation that is then adopted by other states.

The state with the best chance to do this is California with the CaliforniaOnecare.org campaign.  I’ll tell you why I have become a very enthusiastic supporter of this well organized movement below.

Battle of Asculum

Before I proceed let me establish one thing; I think Obama is a great President.  Although he has not done much of what I hoped he do, he has done one thing that in my view makes all the difference in the world; Obama has regained the moral high ground for America. This alone is enough for me to be a loyal supporter of Obama.

But healthcare matters to me so I will keep on fighting until healthcare is available to all, with or without Obama’s support.

The California One Care campaign is where spotlight will move to next.

Why?

Its purpose is to get California Senate Bill 810 (SB 810) passed.

SB 810 is Single Payer full care for all.

It has the support of all the Democratic legislative leadership and most Democratic legislators

California One Care has a detailed roadmap that even takes into account a Schwarzenegger veto and leads to victory (not a Pyrrhic one) by 2012.

It is the tip of the iceberg of a strong coalition of volunteers and committed organizations.

Its upcoming 365 TV spot ad campaign starting with the one by Lill Tomlin will be effective. I have seen the first 32 and I was excited.

California OneCare is also backed by Heathcare for All which has been pushing for Single Payer legislation in California for 15 years!

In the coming weeks, I will highlight much more about California One Care and the looming healthcare battle that will be fought over the next years in California. Many other states (I hope) will also push for similar legislation but California is the ball game. Victory here is victory everywhere.

We expect the insurance companies to play hardball and we are preparing. But we will need all the help we can get. Everything from blogging, boots on the ground, donations, letters to the editors, phone banking, etc.

The action will start in February, when SB 810 is brought to the floor in Sacramento.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • Print
Advertisement
  • joemarkowitz
    If the insurance companies will rejoice why are they spending millions opposing the bill? If Republicans will high five each other why are there no Republican votes for the bill? If the tea baggers will celebrate, why are they marching in the streets trying to kill the bill? Are they all pretending to be unhappy about the bill, but in fact they are really happy? Are they waiting until it has passed to reveal their true feelings? How are you privy to what all these groups really think, but the rest of us are not? Have you infiltrated the secret tea party meetings where they talk about how they really want Congress to do what they are publicly demanding that Congress not do? If so, I would love to hear some details about that.
  • Peggy
    I would like to know how the federal bill might impact SB810. If states are not allowed to opt out of the federal system, can they supplement it with single-payer, or would they have to give up that option? How will those states which already have their own single-payer system, or a similar one, have to accommodate the federal plan?
  • Andy
    I would like to know the answer to this question also.
  • Address to Donate:

    Make checks to: Health Care for All
    sent to:
    Health Care for All
    California OneCare Campaign
    PO Box 2578
    Mill Valley , CA 94942-2578

    The end result on the federal level is the status quo got rattled.
  • Marley Spilman
    Hello,

    I can't find an address anywhere to which I can send a donation by postal mail. I do not donate on line.

    Thank you for your wonderful work.

    Marley Spilman
    spilogs@rawbw.com
  • Cynthia
    Actually, this is a victory for the uninsured and those who are paying way too much for insurance. Middle class Americans will not have to pay more than a small percentage of their income towards health insurance and those with pre-existing conditions can no longer be denied coverage. For those who don't like to pay for insurance company profits, there will be non-profit plans in the exchange. The Senate bill really is a good compromise. A single payer system would be great, but it is not going to happen with all the moderates and conservatives in the house and senate. We have to compromise for the sake of the uninsured and underinsured and those dying and going bankrupt due to a health care system that remains unattainable to millions of Americans. The saying is true: "We can't let the perfect be the enemy of the good".
blog comments powered by Disqus